China’s retail sector comes to the fore
July 1, 2008 7:08 pm
Shanghai residents and visitors both may recall some of the lively pedestrian malls in the city, the most famous being Nanjing East Road going all the way to the scenic Bund. Shanghai’s Wujiang Road is also famous in the city for serving such delicacies as Shengjian (friend dumplings, most unhealthy but oh so delicious) and fermented tofu (usually served fried) known locally as ’stinky tofu.’ One half of Wujiang Road has undergone a facelift that is indicative of the changing consumer landscape in China.
Retail in China can be a mixed bag: French-retailer Carrefour may be having problems, but China’s Lianhua is doing well, and foreign firms such as Staples and UPS are expanding, even as Bertlesmann China closes its retail outlets.
There are clearly winners and losers, but retail consumption overall is the most important driver of growth in the Chinese economy. The picture is bright, according to a report by AT Kearney that ranks China as the fourth most attractive retail market (h/t to China Law Blog).
Here is my article from the June 30 edition of the Shanghai Star Business Journal, with some before and after pictures for your enjoyment.
__________________
As world energy prices begin to affect transportation costs, the appreciating yuan results in a decreased demand for Chinese exports, and a tighter monetary policy starts to reign in inflation, the question now is how China will avoid a dramatic economic slowdown. If Shanghai’s Wujiang Road area is any indication, retail may be the answer to China’s excess supply, with China’s newly-affluent middle-class consumers increasingly demanding more.
People who have been living in Shanghai for longer than three years will have distinctive memories of the old Wujiang Road, the bustling restaurant street running parallel to Nanjing West Road near the subway station and intersection of Shimen No. 1 Road.
The area directly behind the station used to have Chinese eateries and snack stands, push-cart vendors and colorful events such as a weekly English corner. Now, in much the same way the Huangpu River separates Puxi from Pudong, old from new, Wujiang Road stands divided: East of Shimen No. 1 Road, the street remains much as it has always been, while the western half has recently taken on a new look: Redesigned by Singapore’s Frasers Property and rebranded as InPoint, part of the Jing’An Four Seasons mixed-use residential and retail development, western Wujiang Road is home to a newly-renovated shopping arcade.
The loss of yet another part of Shanghai’s historic past aside, it is hard to deny the new layout and selection is vastly improved.
Where once were about twenty small restaurants and shops now stands a mall with space for more than ninety. Hole-in-the-wall bubble-tea stands have been replaced by four coffee chains including the ubiquitous Starbucks. What once was a Chinese snack vendor selling meihuagao (a rare and delicious baked rice cake with red bean paste inside and topped with dried fruit) is now an Iceason. If you don’t like their ice cream, you can go to one of three other frozen dessert shops, such as a DQ and Cold Stone Creamery, or try Honeymoon Dessert, one of the many Hong Kong and Taiwanese-style snack shops.
Much like the Wujiang Road of old, there are sit-down restaurants galore, but now with a corporate-branded flavor. And that’s not even mentioning the shops: Retailers Levi’s, Tissot, and ONLY, and other sellers of everything from stuffed animals and puzzles to jewelry and baubles.
All this stands in stark contrast to the eastern side of Wujiang Road, with its low-priced stinky tofu vendors, fried dumpling shops, and outdoor crawfish restaurants.
In fact, the transformation of Wujiang Road is not unique, and is merely symbolic of how retail is quickly maturing in China. Shanghai has dozens of revitalized or new shopping areas taking shape, and it seems there is now an international-style mall on every major street to replace what once was a local- or state-owned retailer.
Nationwide, China is home to four of the world’s fifteen largest shopping malls, but many of them, including the world’s biggest in Dongguan, Guangdong Province, are having trouble filling up the space. This begs the retail supply question: If you build it, will they come?
Retail spending has been growing rapidly in China. In 2008, urban retail spending is up 22.3 percent in May year on year, with an average rate of 21.1 percent this year so far compared to the same period last year, according to China’s National Bureau of Statistics. This growth seems likely to exceed 2007’s 17 percent overall increase in retail spending, but this is partly expected due to the increased inflation rate compared to 2007. However, by taking inflation out of the calculation, real retail spending has still grown 13 percent in the first quarter of 2008, according to the World Bank’s most recent China Quarterly Update.
Another important indicator is that in 2007, China’s consumption growth - the portion of GDP growth that covers all the goods and services consumed by households - exceeded the growth due to trade or investment to become the top driver of China’s economy, albeit by a slim margin.
Of course, retail spending is only a part of total consumption, but it is a growing part in China as disposable incomes go up. In 2007, average urban salaries increased 18.7 percent, according to NBS figures, nearly four times the 4.8 percent pace of inflation in 2007, and minimum wage levels were increased in many of China’s largest cities. This excess income will drive new retail spending.
Short-term economic statistics aside, where will the long-term support for retail growth come from? There are three major population segments that will keep retail spending high in China’s cities: The white-collar youth, newly-urbanized migrant populations, and the nouveau riche who are spending on big ticket items in the automotive, housing, and luxury markets.
One study by MasterCard estimates that China will have more than 117 million young people with a yearly income greater than US$60,000 by 2016. A recent survey by website zhaopin.com of 6000 urban Shanghainese white-collar workers found that 80 percent had credit cards, and more than half of them already considered themselves in hock to their cards as monthly “card slaves.” The spending power of more than one hundred million high-income consumers who are comfortable with credit card debt, many of whom will live at home until marriage, will be of growing significance to retail sales.
Second, the urbanization trend in China shows no sign of slowing down. The McKinsey Global Institute estimates China will almost double its urban population to 926 million by 2025, with 219 cities of more than a million inhabitants. Each of these cities will have their own Wujiang Road-style pedestrian malls to stimulate consumers’ taste buds and empty their wallets.
Finally, China’s most affluent people, those who can afford their own cars and homes, are literally driving new trends to support their high-end consumption habits. Cars and homes create much related-goods spending, allowing auto-accessories stores such as Japan’s Autobacs, and home-furnishers such as Ikea, to prosper.
As well, the World Luxury Association reported that in 2007 China became the world’s second largest market for luxury goods such as watches, bags, and jewelry, and will top world leader Japan by 2015.
One only needs to look in a three block radius of the new Wujiang Road to see a healthy microcosm of China’s retail environment: Eastern Wujiang Road for the traditionally-minded, the new InPoint shopping street for young consumers, and Nanjing West Road’s high-end fashion and luxury retailers for the affluent. Some may miss the old meihuagao vendor, but China’s economy is not looking back.
Categories: China Supertrends, Consuming, Consumption, Primary Growth Drivers
























7 Responses to “China’s retail sector comes to the fore”
Having a hard time if this article was written with tongue firmly in cheek…
Wujiang Lu Renewed and Reopened…
To say that China has changed over the past decade is an understatement. With its cities expanding upwards as fast as they expand outwards, the rate of development within China is nothing short of breath-taking. As construction cranes give way to more …
Hi Micah, this post was meant to be a little tongue-in-cheek, while pointing out the serious need for China’s retail service sector develop when exports start to decline.
In fact I am one of those people who misses the ‘old’ Wujiang Road (and I loved the creepy guy statue). I fear eastern Wujiang Road will soon be gone as well: I saw a city development plan that indicated it would become a green-space park. Zhen kexi!
Meihuagao was one of my favorite snacks and, since the renovation of western Wujiang Road, I haven’t been able to find them again. That said, the new design of Wujiang Road is better: Cleaner, bigger, brighter. But can anybody love the fact there a four coffee shops, four ice cream shops (plus a Beard Papa), a Subway, Yoshinoya, 85 Degrees bakery, a Chamate (Yi Cha Yi Zuo) and a Tissot brand store thrown in for good measure? Do we really need more of these things? Give me my meihuagao back, please.
@ Adex360 - I think large Chinese cities such as Shanghai are quickly adopting the same global mashup of trademarked retailers that can be seen in any mall throughout Asia and around the world, so I’m not going to be a brand-Luddite either, but I honestly hope that the balance between old and new can be maintained, and that China develops more of its own brands before its streets are overwhelmed by foreign brands. Can Be For Time tea houses and Tea Storm kiosks hold their own against the likes of Starbucks?
With higher rents in the city core, the question is whether the mom-and-pop restaurants can handle the rent and survive vs. fancy brands that may not necessarily have high rates of turnover but have better financial backing. If they can’t, then they’ll keep being pushed to the side streets and/or outskirts of the district.
As for the Mastercard salary forecast, I think they’re basing that $60,000 average salary by 2016 for 1/4th of the Chinese urban population on some wildly optimistic assumptions. Stats from the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) late last year showed that the average white-collar worker in Shanghai earned 5,350 yuan ($717) a month or ~RMB8,400 a year. They must be expecting the RMB to hit parity with the US$ in less than a decade…
[...] of Shanghai’s old neighborhoods isn’t exactly breaking news, but takes a fresh look at the phenomenon, specifically the gentilization of Wujiang Lu behind West Nanjing Lu. Starbucks [...]
[...] expat market size is increasing. Singapore’s Frasers Property, previously featured in our article on the redevelopment of Shanghai’s Wujiang Road, plans to open 20 new serviced apartment [...]
[...] China Supertrends covers the recent reopening of Wujiang Lu (吴江路), one of Shanghai’s favorite pedestrian arcades, after having cocooned itself over the past year to remodel itself to be more “tourist-friendly.” People who have been living in Shanghai for longer than three years will have distinctive memories of the old Wujiang Road, the bustling restaurant street running parallel to Nanjing West Road near the subway station and intersection of Shimen No. 1 Road. [...]
Care to comment?